Mazda CX-5 vs Toyota RAV4: Driving Fun vs Proven Reliability

FeatureMazda CX-5Toyota RAV4
ClassCompact SUVCompact SUV
Fuel Economy25-31 MPG27-35 MPG
Cargo Space30.9 cu ft37.6 cu ft
Reliability8/109/10
Insurance Cost$$$$
Key StrengthsBest-in-class handling, premium interior quality, upscale design, engaging driveMore cargo space, better fuel economy, stronger resale value, proven reliability
Best ForDrivers who want a compact SUV that feels like a luxury vehicleFamilies who prioritize practicality and long-term dependability

Our Verdict

The CX-5 is the driver's choice in the compact SUV segment — its handling, interior quality, and design punch well above its price class. The RAV4 is the practical family choice with more cargo space, better fuel economy, and Toyota's bulletproof reliability. For Tampa drivers who want their daily commute to feel special, the CX-5 delivers. For those who need maximum utility and worry-free ownership, the RAV4 wins.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Mazda CX-5 a luxury SUV?

Not officially, but it feels like one. The CX-5's interior materials, build quality, and driving dynamics rival luxury SUVs costing $10,000 more. It is one of the best-kept secrets in the compact SUV market.

Why does the RAV4 have more cargo space than the CX-5?

The RAV4 prioritizes interior utility in its design, while the CX-5 prioritizes driving dynamics and a sleek profile. The RAV4 offers 37.6 cu ft vs 30.9 cu ft for the CX-5 — a meaningful difference for Tampa families loading beach gear and groceries.

See These Vehicles In Person

Nothing beats a test drive. Visit Tampa Autohaus to see both options up close.

Schedule a Test Drive View Inventory