| Feature | Toyota Highlander | Honda Pilot |
|---|---|---|
| Class | Midsize 3-Row SUV | Midsize 3-Row SUV |
| Fuel Economy | 21-29 MPG | 20-27 MPG |
| Cargo Space | 16.0 cu ft (behind 3rd row) | 16.5 cu ft (behind 3rd row) |
| Reliability | 9/10 | 8/10 |
| Insurance Cost | $$ | $$ |
| Key Strengths | Best-in-class reliability, available hybrid, smooth ride, excellent resale value | More spacious third row, more cargo room, better highway ride, family-friendly features |
| Best For | Families who prioritize reliability and long-term value in a 3-row SUV | Larger families who need a usable third row and maximum interior space |
Both are outstanding 3-row family SUVs. The Highlander wins on reliability and offers an efficient hybrid option that is perfect for Tampa stop-and-go commuting. The Pilot wins on interior space — its third row is genuinely usable for adults, while the Highlander's third row is better suited for kids. For Tampa families who need to regularly carry six or more passengers, the Pilot is the practical choice. For long-term ownership peace of mind, the Highlander is hard to beat.
The Toyota Highlander is one of the most reliable 3-row SUVs on the market. The Honda Pilot is also above average. Both are significantly more reliable than domestic competitors like the Explorer or Traverse.
The Highlander's third row is tight for adults on long trips but works fine for shorter rides. The Pilot offers noticeably more third-row space and is more comfortable for adult passengers in the back.
Nothing beats a test drive. Visit Tampa Autohaus to see both options up close.